Elements of Grading: Research has shown that the quality of feedback is one of the most important factors in improving student learning. Elements of Grading addresses problems with the primary source of feedback for students: grades. Author Douglas Reeves argues that grades must meet four essential criteria: -Accuracy. How can we ensure that grading systems are the result of evidence and reason rather than individual judgment? -Fairness. How can we ensure that grades are based on performance rather than gender, ethnicity, or socioeconomic status? -Specificity. How can we make sure grades are specific enough to help students improve their performance, rather than simply ranking them? -Timeliness. How can we ensure that students receive fair, accurate, and specific feedback while they still have the time and motivation to use it? In addressing these four issues, Elements of Grading does not offer an ultimate answer or perfect system but shows how to begin a constructive, evidence-based conversation about improving grading systems. Reeves analyzes the main features of the grading systems many schools use today (such as the 100-point system and the policy of giving no points for missing work), evaluating each of them by his four criteria. While addressing common arguments against reform, he offers practical suggestions to teachers to make the grading process not only more accurate, fair, specific, and timely, but quicker and more efficient as well. The book includes examples, case studies, and opportunities for reflection to facilitate individual and school-wide examinations of grading policies.
The discussion around grading is one of the most passionate conversations I hear educators talk about! How educator grade students is extremely personal and people have so many different values when it comes to student assessments and grading practices.
In Douglas Reeves’ book, he opens with an introduction that addresses why grading is so important and the importance of personal believes and values around grading and their relationship to the evidence surrounding assessment.
In each subsequent chapter, Reeves explores the purpose of grading and importance of grading as a feedback mechanism for students. He also digs into the math and fallacies with the archaic 100-90-80-70-60-50 system we’ve used for decades.
The remaining chapters explore how to improve the accuracy of grading and feedback for students, including suggestions for collaborative scoring and how to avoid mathematical distortions. He also writes about how fairness plays into a grading policy.
Reeves stresses the importance of providing quality feedback as a way to promote student growth, rather than just a single numerical value. When students received detailed, timely feedback, they can better understand their actual progress and strive for improvement based on in depth feedback rather a single number or letter grade.
In the last part of the text, Reeves discusses how schools can move toward uniform, researched-based grading policies and how to address staff reactions, values, and behaviors.
Ultimately, we want students to strive for growth during their time in our classrooms, and Reeves’ practical and research-based guidelines and suggestions promote a culture of equity and success for every student. If your school or staff is grappling with grading practices and how to reconcile decades of tradition against research-based practices, I highly recommend this book!
Note: English with Steil is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.
